No I don't think Ellen will make a good judge. She is a comedian...she is funny..very funny. What does she know about music? After she guest judged "So you think you can dance" and basically was making jokes the whole time and really had no serious input, the powers at be thinks she can judge singing?? I doubt I will watch it anymore, because she will really make a mockery of the show.
Don't neccessarily need Paula back, but WHY Ellen???
I don't think I'll be watching anymore. I like Ellen but she has no business being on American Idol. What does she know about music and singing and giving professional advice in regards to their careers and what kind of voice they have etc. etc. etc. That's like the Top Chef giving advice to Picasso. She has NO CLUE!!!
Posted on Thursday, 9/10/2009 - 9:59 a.m. PDT — by cbarney
Comments
Joined: Mar 2007
Current Posts: 446
305 votes and no comments? All I can think of is, will Ellen be getting up to dance during the performances?
Joined: Sep 2009
Current Posts: 1
No I don't think Ellen will make a good judge. She is a comedian...she is funny..very funny. What does she know about music? After she guest judged "So you think you can dance" and basically was making jokes the whole time and really had no serious input, the powers at be thinks she can judge singing?? I doubt I will watch it anymore, because she will really make a mockery of the show.
Don't neccessarily need Paula back, but WHY Ellen???
Joined: Sep 2009
Current Posts: 1
I don't think I'll be watching anymore. I like Ellen but she has no business being on American Idol. What does she know about music and singing and giving professional advice in regards to their careers and what kind of voice they have etc. etc. etc. That's like the Top Chef giving advice to Picasso. She has NO CLUE!!!