Do you believe faith has a place in m...


CCTModerator
CCTModerator's picture

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 129
This forum topic is based on a poll conducted earlier. Voting has been closed.   Do you believe faith has a place in medical treatment?
  • Yes, prayer can work miracles for the sick.
  • No, faith is nice but no substitute for medicine.
  • Maybe, since studies can't explain all outcomes.
  • When you hope you've enough cash to pay the bill!
No votes yet

MikeSar
MikeSar's picture

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 242
Prayer to God requires a belief in God. No God, no prayer. If there is a God, he must be all-powerful, God must be omnipotent. If you pray, it is because you believe in God, but God must be omnipotent, or there is no God, therefore, you must also believe that God can heal you. But, if you have to read it here, obviously, you do not believe in God nor in prayer. Going swiming for Christmas? Dont' catch a cold, Y'hear? MikeSar
nicolse
nicolse's picture

Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 1
Wine is very nesseccary of our digestion <a href='http://www.wineclubdirectory.net'> Wine Club </a>
bucksavage
bucksavage's picture

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 220
What's a "gene poll" ? Is that where you ask a bunch of people what type of denim pants they like to wear?
Clayton
Clayton's picture

Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 1138
You caught me, I meant Gene Pool not gene poll.
bucksavage
bucksavage's picture

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 220
About the gene pool, I was just having a discussion with a ten-year-old about why we humans haven't evolved super eyesight or even greater intelligence. It's all about tradeoffs. If you have too high an IQ, you become evolutionarily unfit. Unable to attract a mate. Prone to criminality and depression. Possibly putting all your effort into raising one young who turns out to be a non-breeder (not that there's anything wrong with that). That's why one guy I know is raising his son to be on the "top of the Bell curve," average in every way. For his child's happiness and for maximum evolutionary fitness.
Clayton
Clayton's picture

Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 1138
About the gene pool, I was just having a discussion with a ten-year-old about why we humans haven't evolved super eyesight or even greater intelligence. It's all about tradeoffs. If you have too high an IQ, you become evolutionarily unfit. Unable to attract a mate. Prone to criminality and depression. Possibly putting all your effort into raising one young who turns out to be a non-breeder (not that there's anything wrong with that). That's why one guy I know is raising his son to be on the "top of the -->-->-->Bell-->--> curve," average in every way. For his child's happiness and for maximum evolutionary fitness. -->--> --> Another, equally logical conclusion is that humans should not be allowed to randomly breed, (this was Hitler’s basic proposal of course). Bovine, (cattle) breeding has been very successful for the last 400 yrs(?) with emphasizing genetic characteristics—so logically it should work in humans.  --> --> But as a human with a voice, (unlike a cow), I might protest that plan.
bucksavage
bucksavage's picture

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 220
It would be interesting to see what aliens could do if they came down and dominated us, and they decided to start breeding humans like we bred dogs. How tall could some humans become? How fast? How small? What about cool black-and-white spotted skin and conical craniums?
Clayton
Clayton's picture

Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 1138
Interesting experiment, but not one I would want to participate in.  In the end our individuality supercedes our commitment to evolutionary growth as a race. An interesting aside is that is precisely this individuality that causes political systems predicated on social good over individual rights to fail. It means we are pretty lucky to be the dominate at this time.
bucksavage
bucksavage's picture

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 220
I wasn't really thinking that forced breeding to create freakish humans would be "evolutionary growth as a race." But then who agrees on absolutely everything? All political systems include a mix of "social good" and "individual rights." How long a system lasts depends on a lot of factors. A system based on pure selfishness won't last much longer than Ayn Rand's failed little cult.
Clayton
Clayton's picture

Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 1138
I wasn't really thinking that forced breeding to create freakish humans would be "evolutionary growth as a race." But then who agrees on absolutely everything?-->-->--> If you think about it any change in a species is evolutionary. The spectrum of change is not linear, it’s n-dimensional; so who are we to decide what change in humans is good or bad? We judge the results of selective breeding by the extent to which they serve us.-->--> All political systems include a mix of "social good" and "individual rights." How long a system lasts depends on a lot of factors. A system based on pure selfishness won't last much longer than Ayn Rand's failed little cult.-->--> More to the point, political systems are like a species in that they are ever-changing, Their development is not linear, and the balance between social rights and individualism is never acceptable to everyone, (I am willing to guess that the percentage of people fully satisfied with the blend is very small). Moreover, no one knows what development is good or bad at the time it is adopted. Contesting for a better balance according to our own priorities, needs, and secondarily our professed philosophies is the only constant of human society. In this context, permanent peace is never really achievable --> --> One final point for consideration—political systems really do not end, unless every member of that society ceases to exist. When a system fails, it fails to satisfy the needs of a large portion of that society. The system is then modified, sometimes drastically, but it never really ceases. --> --> I am not sure where all this speculation is going, but the journey is fun.-->-->

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate the change.